Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

News reporting of the January 12, 2010, Haiti earthquake: The role of common misconceptions

David Alexander, PhD

Abstract


The Haiti earthquake of January 12, 2010, was one of the worst seismic disasters of the last half-century. Given the severity of damage to infrastructure and the gravity of the humanitarian crisis, it was particularly difficult for journalists to report the situation accurately during the early stages of the crisis. In relation to the Haitian catastrophe, this article considers 10 misassumptions that commonly appear in news reports about disaster. They include “myths” about the inevitability of disease, the prevalence of panic, and the need to impose martial law. Behind the misassumptions is a widely disseminated but wholly inaccurate model of the breakdown of society, which is greatly at variance with the observational definition by sociologists of the postdisaster “therapeutic community.” This article concludes that the misassumptions are, at least in part, alive and well. Some of the less responsible news media enthusiastically propagated them without checking the reality on the ground in Haiti. However, there are signs that at last the more thoughtful media are prepared to question the myths of disaster. In part this is clearly because influential people in the humanitarian relief effort have made a special effort to make journalists aware that certain notions are misassumptions— for example, that unburied dead bodies give rise to disease epidemics. Nevertheless, it is not yet clear whether we are entering a new age of more responsible reporting of disasters by the mass media.

Keywords


news reporting, journalism, earthquake, disaster, emergency relief, misconception, Haiti

Full Text:

PDF

References


Henley J: Haiti: A long descent to Hell. The Guardian, London. January 14, 2010.

Celik S, Corbacioglu S: Role of information in collective action in dynamic disaster environments. Disasters. 2010; 34(1): 137-154.

Needham RD: The cosmopolite-localite model: Newspaper types of natural hazard information potentials. Environ Manage. 1986; 10(2): 271-284.

Ingram D: Visiting firemen. New Int. 1977; 53: 10-12.

Alexander DE: Forty-six common misconceptions about disaster. Available at emergency-planning.blogspot.com/2008/12/forty-fourcommon- misconceptions-about.html. Accessed December 22, 2008.

Scanlon TJ, Luukko R, Morton G: Media coverage of crisis: Better than reported, worse than necessary. J Q. 1978; 55: 68-72.

Noji EK: The nature of disaster. In Noji EK (ed.): The Public Health Consequences of Disasters. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1999:3-36.

Alexander DE: Misconceptions as a barrier to teaching about disasters. Prehosp Disaster Med. 2007; 22(2): 95-103.

Tierney K, Bevc C, Kuligowski E: Metaphors matter: Disaster myths, media frames, and their consequences in Hurricane Katrina. Ann Am Acad Pol Soc Sci. 2006; 604(1): 57-81.

UNDP: Human Development Report 2009. Overcoming Barriers: Human Mobility and Development. United Nations Development Programme. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009.

Paskett C, Philoctete C-E: Soil conservation in Haiti. J Soil Water Conserv. 1990; 45(4): 457-459.

Kelly C: Problems of food shortage assessment in Haiti. Disasters. 1983; 7(2): 97-101.

Mason J, Cavalie P: Malaria epidemic in Haiti following a hurricane. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1965; 14: 533-539.

Vogt J: A glimpse at the historical seismicity of the West Indies. Ann Geophys. 2004; 47(2-3): 465-476.

Alexander DE: The Florence floods: What the papers said. Environ Manage. 1980; 4(1): 27-34.

Alexander DE: Newspaper reporting of the Florence bomb. Int J Mass Emerg Disasters. 1995; 13(1): 45-65.

Goltz JD: Are the news media responsible for the disaster myths? A content analysis of emergency response imagery. Int J Mass Emerg Disasters. 1984; 2(3): 345-368.

Gaddy GD, Tanjong E: Earthquake coverage by the Western press. J Commun. 1986; 36(2): 105-112.

Quarantelli EL: Realities and mythologies in disaster films. Communications. 1985: 11: 31-44.

Mitchell JT, Thomas DSK, Hill AA, et al.: Catastrophe in reel life versus real life: Perpetuating disaster myth through Hollywood films. Int J Mass Emerg Disasters. 2000; 18(3): 383-402.

IFRCRCS: World Disasters Report 2009. Focus on Early Warning, Early Action. Geneva: International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, 2009.

Tierney KJ: Disaster beliefs and institutional interests: Recycling disaster myths in the aftermath of 9-11. In Clarke L (ed.): Terrorism and Disaster: New Threats, New Ideas. Research in Social Problems and Public Policy, No. 11. Stamford, CT: JAI Press, 2003: 33-51.

Arnold JL: Disaster myths and Hurricane Katrina 2005: Can public officials and the media learn to provide responsible crisis communication during disasters? Prehosp Disaster Med. 2006; 21(1): 1-4.

De Ville de Goyet C: Stop propagating disaster myths. Prehosp Disaster Med. 1999; 14(1): 9-10.

De Ville de Goyet C: Stop propagating disaster myths. Aust J Emerg Manage. 1999; 14(4): 26-28.

De Ville de Goyet C: Stop propagating disaster myths. INCEDE Newsl. 1999; 8(2): 6-7.

Pan American Health Organization (PAHO): Management of Dead Bodies in Disaster Situations.Washington, DC: PAHO, 2004.

Morgan O: Infectious disease risks from dead bodies following natural disasters. Rev Panam Salud Publica. 2004; 15(5): 307-312.

Haiti: Fear of epidemic grows. Available at www.speroforum. com/a/25579/Haiti-fear-of-epidemic-grows. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Haiti now tipped to get a disease epidemic. The Australian. UK Daily Telegraph. January 22, 2010.

Haiti estimates quake toll 100,000, fears epidemic. New Kerala (India), January 17, 2010.

Blake PA: Communicable disease control. In Gregg MB (ed.): The Public Health Consequences of Disasters. Atlanta, GA: Federal Centers for Disease Control, 1989: 5-10.

Floret N, Viel J-F, Mauny F, et al.: Negligible risk for epidemics after geophysical disasters. Emerg Infect Dis. 2006; 12(4): 543-548.

Roure C, Khalakdina A, Ungchusak K, et al.: Surveillance, early warning alert, and response: Communicable and vector-borne diseases. Prehosp Disaster Med. 2005; 20(6): 399-403.

SOSChindrensVillages: Haiti earthquake: Interview with Leonie Saint-Ange: Nurse with SOS Children's Villages Haiti. Available at www.youtube.com/watch?v=2UCVsjS0NVY. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Haiti now tipped to get a disease epidemic.Available at www.news. com.au/world/haiti-tipped-for-disease-epidemic/story-e6frfkyi- 1225822355797. Accessed February 4, 2010.

After the quake comes the disease: Can Haiti cope? Time Magazine. January 13, 2010.

Diseases likely problem for Haitian earthquake survivors. The Winnipeg Free Press syndicated to the Canadian Press. January 18, 2010.

Coburn A, Spence R: Earthquake Protection. 2nd ed. Chichester, UK:Wiley, 2002.

Haiti quake rescuers find girl alive after 15 days. Available at news.bbc.co.uk. Accessed January 28, 2010.

Celizic M: Buried in Haiti rubble, U.S. dad wrote goodbyes. Today Show. Available at today.com. Accessed January 19, 2010.

Quarantelli EL: Looting and Antisocial Behavior in Disasters. Preliminary Paper No. 205. Newark, DE: Disaster Research Center, University of Delaware, 1994.

Barsky LE: Disaster realities following Katrina: Revisiting the looting myth. In Natural Hazards Center (ed.): Learning from Catastrophe: Quick Response Research in the Wake of Hurricane Katrina. Boulder, CO: Institute of Behavioral Science, University of Colorado, 2006: 215-234.

Kinney A: “Looting” or “finding”? Salon.com; September 1, 2005. Available at http://dir.salon.com/story/news/feature/2005/09/01/photo_ controversy/index.html. Accessed February 3, 2010.

Sherwell P, Sawer P: Haiti earthquake: Looting and gunfights break out. UK Daily Telegraph. January 16, 2010.

Loot mob anarchy holds up Haiti earthquake aid. UK Daily Mirror. January 18, 2010.

Whittell G: Lynch mobs turn on looters amid Haiti aid crisis. The Times (London), January 18, 2010.

Klarreich K: Haiti earthquake dairy: Looting or survival? Christian Science Monitor. January 22, 2010.

Haiti earthquake: Looters, machete gangs and fights for water as aid STILL struggles to get through. AlterMedia International; January 16, 2010. Available at www.altermedia.info. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Barton AH: Communities in Disaster: A Sociological Analysis of Collective Stress Situations. New York: Doubleday, 1970.

Quarantelli EL, Dynes RR: Response to social crisis and disaster. Annu Rev Sociol. 1977; 3: 23-49.

OCHA: Guidelines on the Use of Foreign Military and Civil Defence Assets in Disaster Relief—“Oslo Guidelines.” Geneva: United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Relief, 2007.

Bertolaso G: Italian official condemns Haiti earthquake relief as ‘vanity parade’. The Guardian (UK), January 25, 2010.

Growth of aid and the decline of humanitarianism. Lancet. 2010; 375(9711): 253.

Eley O: US military to enforce state of emergency in Haiti. International Movement for a Just World; January 26, 2010. Available at www.just-international.org. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Davis N: Haiti police battle to keep streets safe; January 19, 2010. Available at news.bbc.co.uk. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Vance LM: Should the US military go to Haiti?; January 15, 2010. Available at LewRockwell.com. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Strong aftershock shakes Haiti, week after earthquake; January 20, 2010. Available at news.bbc.co.uk. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Lal V: Marines as the face of America; Haiti’s earthquake II; January 25, 2010. Available at vinaylal.wordpress.com. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Johnson NR: Panic and the breakdown of social order: Popular myth, social theory, empirical evidence. Sociol Focus. 1987; 20(3): 171-183.

Dynes RR: Panic and the vision of collective incompetence. Nat Hazards Obs. 2006; 31(2): 5-6.

Keating JF: The myth of panic. Fire J. 1982; 77: 57-61, 147.

Laing A, Leonard T: Haiti earthquake: Gunshots and panic as locals fight back against looters. Daily Telegraph. January 14, 2010.

Hundreds feared dead in Haiti earthquake. ABC News; January 13, 2010. Available at www.abc.net.au. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Land J: Widespread panic as new earthquake hits Haiti; January 20, 2010. Available at 24dash.com. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Wallace AFC: Human Behaviour During Extreme Situations. Washington, DC: National Academy of Sciences, 1956.

Drabek TE: Human System Response to Disaster: An Inventory of Sociological Findings. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1985.

Bolin R: Household and Community Recovery After Earthquakes (Monograph no. 56). Boulder, CO: Natural Hazards Research and Applications Information Center, 1993.

Katz JM: Panic, looting and triage after major Haiti quake. Associated Press. January 13, 2010.

Fraser C: Haiti can lead quake recovery, summit told; January 26, 2010. Available at news.bbc.co.uk. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Noji EK: Medical and healthcare aspects of the 1988 earthquake in Soviet Armenia. Earthquake Spectra. 1989; 5(S1): 101-107.

Pujawan N, Kurniati N, Wessiani NA: Supply chain management for disaster relief operations: Principles and case studies. Int J Logistics Syst Manage. 2009; 5(6): 679-692.

Pan American Health Organization (PAHO): WHO-PAHO Guidelines for the Use of Foreign Field Hospitals in the Aftermath of Sudden-Impact Disasters.Washington, DC: PAHO, 2003.

Von Schreeb J, Riddez L, Samnegård H, et al.: Foreign field hospitals in the recent sudden-impact disasters in Iran, Haiti, Indonesia, and Pakistan. Prehosp Disaster Med. 2008; 23(2): 144-153.

Case D: Haiti: Help with money, not stuff. After every major disaster, misguided donations actually worsen the suffering; January 13, 2010. Available at www.globalpost.com. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Haiti’s medical crisis: Treating crushed survivors. Time Magazine. January 21, 2010.

Chase S: 1st Canadian field hospital deploying to epicenter of Haitian earthquake. The Daily Observer (Canada). January 23, 2010.

Haiti: Babies born in Red Cross field hospital. British Red Cross Press Release. January 22, 2010.

Mount M: Military official: US hospital ship in Haiti near capacity. CNN World; January 28, 2010. Available at www.cnn.com. Accessed February 4, 2010.

Middleton N, O’Keefe P: Disasters and Development: The Politics of Humanitarian Aid. London: Pluto Press, 1998.

Bennett R, Daniel M: Media reporting of Third World disasters: The journalist’s perspective. Disaster Prev Manage. 2002; 11(1): 33-42.

Habayeb S, Bolton S, Jones M, et al.: The role of media and communication [Indonesian tsunami]. Prehosp Disaster Med. 2005; 20(6): 442-445.

Glass RI, Noji EK: Epidemiologic surveillance following disasters. In Halperin WE, Baker EL, Monson RR (eds.): Public Health Surveillance. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1992: 195-204.

Paul BK: Disaster relief efforts: An update. Prog Dev Stud. 2006; 6(3): 211-223.

Winfield N: UN: US-run airport in Haiti to give aid planes, not US military, priority landing rights. Associated Press. January 18, 2010.

Stallings RD: Media discourse and the social construction of risk. Soc Probl. 1990; 37: 501-516.

Wenger D: Mass media and disasters. Preliminary Paper No. 98. Newark, DE: Disaster Research Center, University of Delaware, 1985.

Storey K, Beckett J: Heroes on Haiti earthquake mission. Manchester Evening News. January 16, 2010.

Dodds P: Protests, frustrations erupt as earthquake aid hits bottlenecks after reaching Haiti. Los Angeles Times. February 3, 2010.

Little R: Hospital ship greeted by Haiti’s stark reality: Victims stream aboard from a steady procession of helicopters as mercy ship arrives in Port-au-Prince. Baltimore Sun. January 21, 2010.

Gutman S: Israel builds [sic] a field hospital in Haiti: Anti- Zionists not fooled!; January 19, 2010.Available at Telegraph.co.uk. Accessed February 4, 2010.

President Obama reacts to Haiti’s earthquake. So, Obama waits 3 days to address a terror attack on the U.S. but moments to address a earthquake in Haiti. Fox News; January 12, 2010.

Help Haiti, no military: Since earthquake Cuban docs treated 10,000 people. Cuba News Agency; January 21, 2010.

Canadian Haiti Action Network: Canadian and US Military should not treat victims of Haiti’s earthquake like enemy combatants; January 19, 2010. Available at www.mediacoop.ca. Accessed February 4, 2010.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.5055/jem.2010.0036

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2018 Journal of Emergency Management