Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

Toxic gas dispersion models: Can they predict protective action distances in case of a chemical spill?

John S. Nordin, PhD

Abstract


Emergency responders often use a gas dispersion model to estimate downwind airborne concentrations of a toxic chemical in case of a chemical spill accident. For protecting the public, a protective action distance from the spill source is established based on the distance where the toxic concentration drops below some level of concern. This distance is used as a basis for evacuation of the public from the area or for instructions to shelter-in-place. However, in real-world accidents, the responders neither know the amount of chemicals released into the air nor the duration of the release, and moreover, the concentrations of chemicals at any location will vary over time. Depending on what input information is put into the model, different results will be obtained. The problem of what input parameters to use for gas dispersion modeling is illustrated for a hypothetical 90-ton chlorine railcar accident, where the railcar is breached. Different answers for a protective action distance are obtained depending on whether the tables in the Emergency Response Guidebook or any of the popular gas dispersion models are used. Very different answers are obtained from any model depending on whether whole of the chemical is released at once as a gas or aerosol or whether the liquefied chlorine evaporates slowly inside a ruptured 90-ton railcar tank, and also the weather conditions. To avoid misunderstandings, people who use models to establish a protective action distance must also communicate the circumstances in which the models are used, eg, “worst possible what-if scenario,” etc, or “nighttime stable conditions,” or other situations.

Keywords


dispersion, mathematical model, toxic chemicals

Full Text:

PDF

References


ALOHA Model and Manual, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 2007: Internet download from Environmental Protection Agency website. Available at http://www.epa.gov/emergencies/content/cameo/aloha.htm.

Sheesley DC, Nordin JS, King SB, et al.: Chemical Dispersion Modeling Project, 1995 Kit Fox Field Demonstration, DOE Nevada Hazardous Spill Center, Final Report. Volume 1: Experiment Description and Data Processing WRI-98-R019a. Wyoming: Western Research Institute, 1998.

Sheesley DC, Nordin JS, King SB, et al.: Chemical Dispersion Modeling Project, 1995 Kit Fox Field Demonstration, DOE Nevada Hazardous Spill Center, Final Report. Volume II: Data Analysis for Enhanced Roughness Tests WRI-98-R019b. Wyoming: Western Research Institute, 1998.

Thomerson J: Chlorine Vapor Suppression Tests, Dow Chemical USA, Chlor-Alkali Technology Center Internal report A-1230. Freeport TX, 1990. Available at http://www.ac-research.org/stfdb/DOE%20HSC%20Database%20documentation.PDF.

King SB, Sheesley D, Routh T, et al.: The Kit Fox Field Demonstration and Data Set International Conference and Workshop on Modeling the Consequences of Accidental Releases of Hazardous Materials, presented in San Francisco, CA. New York: American Institute of Chemical Engineers, 1999.

Anon, The Chlorine Manual, The Chlorine Institute,Washington, DC, 2000. Available at http://www.chlorineinstitute.org.

Ermak DL: User’s Manual for SLAB: An Atmospheric Dispersion Model for Denser-Than-Air Releases UCRL-MA-105607. Livermore, CA: Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, 1990.

Emergency Response Guidebook (published jointly by Transport Canada, US Department of Transportation, and Secretariat of Transport (Mexico)). Available at http://hazmat.dot.gov/pubs/erg/erg2008_eng.pdf.

Brown DF, Freeman WA, Carhart RA, et al.: Development of the Table of Initial Isolation and Protective Action Distances for the 2004 Emergency Response Guidebook. Illinois: Argonne National Laboratories ANL/DIS-05-2, 2005. Available at http://hazmat.dot.gov/pubs/erg/Argonne_Report08042005.pdf. [comment: The developmental report for the 2008 ERG was not available at the writing of this paper.]

Havens J, Spicer T: A Dispersion Model for Elevated Dense Gas Jet Chemical Releases. University of Arkansas and US Environmental Protection Agency, EPA-450/4-88-006a, 1988. Available at http://www.epa.gov/scram001/userg/other/degugv1.pdf.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.5055/jem.2008.0035

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2018 Journal of Emergency Management